News press

GBH’s response to the Senate Committee of Inquiry’s report on manufacturers’ and large retailers’ margins

GBH

“Tackling the high cost of living in France’s overseas territories is a crucial issue that deserves a debate based on facts, verified figures and an accurate assessment.” Stéphane Hayot, CEO of GBH

“Every day, all our teams work tirelessly to offer the lowest possible prices and the best possible shopping experience, while supporting the development of local production wherever we operate.

Against this backdrop, the Senate Committee of Inquiry into manufacturers’ and large retailers’ margins invited us to give evidence in our capacity as a major retailer in France’s overseas territories. We fully embraced this responsibility, as tackling the high cost of living must involve all economic and political stakeholders.

Our participation in this collective effort was marked by commitment and transparency: we gave evidence under oath on 16 April 2026 and submitted 31 pages of detailed figures, including information covered by business confidentiality.

However, following the adoption of the report on 21 May 2026, our group wishes to address several inaccurate or incomplete statements contained in it, which undermine the validity of its analysis:

→ In 2023, the Conseil d’État explicitly ruled out the existence of oligopolies in the large-scale retail sector on Réunion Island. Furthermore, in 2026, both the French Competition Authority and IEDOM carried out highly detailed analyses of price and margin formation in Martinique compared with mainland France. Neither study mentions any risk of insufficient competition, nor does the word ‘oligopoly’ appear in either of them. In Martinique, for example, seven independent retailers operate in the market—the same number as in mainland France, despite Martinique having a population 160 times smaller.

→ Regarding our relationships with local suppliers: when GBH acquired Vindemia’s assets on Réunion Island, the French Competition Authority praised ‘the unprecedented nature, in the Authority’s decision-making practice, of the commitments made by the group to protect suppliers.’ Compliance with these commitments was monitored for five years by an independent trustee.

→ The largest price gap between mainland France and the overseas territories is found in French Polynesia, the only French overseas territory in which GBH does not operate.

→ The net margin of our food retail business in the French overseas departments and regions is around 2%. This figure was confirmed by the French Competition Authority in its February 2026 opinion and by IEDOM in its February 2026 study. Both also confirmed that this margin level is comparable to that of the large-scale retail sector in mainland France. The consolidated rate of 4% sometimes cited in the report covers all the group’s activities—automotive, agri-food and food services—not food retail alone.

→ Seeking the causes of the high cost of living in the margins earned by major retailers is a dead end. A 2026 IEDOM study confirms this: ‘The margin levels of the various retail and wholesale operators in Martinique play only a limited role in the observed gap in consumer food prices between Martinique and mainland France.’

→ The Senate Committee of Inquiry’s report itself acknowledges that, ‘despite intensive legislative activity, the situation has not improved significantly’ since 2009. The underlying assessment therefore needs to be seriously reconsidered.

→ The real causes of the high cost of living are structural: import and freight costs that supermarkets in mainland France do not have to bear—and which account for 33% of purchasing costs according to the French Competition Authority—as well as insularity, small market size and local taxation.

The agreement to tackle the high cost of living, signed in Martinique on 16 October 2024, demonstrates that prices fall when structural factors are addressed. The Territorial Collectivity of Martinique reduced dock dues to zero, the French State abolished VAT on 69 product categories covering 6,000 items, and major retailers made a significant effort on margins. The result has already been a 12% reduction.

If the public authorities offset import and freight costs and mainland French suppliers introduce export pricing—measures included in the 2024 Martinique agreement and whose implementation is the responsibility of Parliament and the French State—the reduction could reach 20% in our stores.

We are ready to implement these reductions as soon as the public authorities have fully applied the measures set out in the Martinique agreement.

All figures cited in this post come from authoritative sources that are independent of our company: the French Competition Authority, the Conseil d’État, IEDOM and INSEE. Anyone can verify them, including by consulting GBH’s consolidated financial statements—covering both the holding company and its subsidiaries—which have been published since 2024, beyond our statutory obligations.

Solutions exist to tackle the high cost of living. However, they require an accurate assessment of its real causes. This is the purpose of the letter we sent to the Senate Committee of Inquiry.”
Stéphane Hayot, CEO of GBH

Read GBH’s letter to the Senate Committee of Inquiry: click here.